Functional and Stylish: A Cast Iron Franklin Stove from Catoctin Iron Furnace

Francis Lukezic, MAC Lab Conservator

The Catoctin Iron Furnace was in operation from 1776 to 1903 and remnants of this once industrious facility can still be seen in the Cunningham Falls State Park, in Frederick County, Maryland. During its working life, the furnace produced raw pig iron, ammunition during the Revolutionary War, and household items such as stoves, utensils, and tools (Anderson 2013).

Recently, the Catoctin Furnace Historical Society brought several iron objects in their collection to the MAC Lab to receive conservation. The objects are items that were either made or used at the furnace and required cleaning to remove soil and corrosion on the surface, followed by the application of protective coatings. One of these objects is a cast iron Franklin stove consisting of eight plates that, when assembled, neatly fit into a fireplace (Figure 1). Two of the stove plates proudly display information about its place of manufacture, CATOCTIN and W. MAYBURRY. Willoughby Mayburry owned and operated Catoctin Furnace from 1811 to 1820 (Anderson 2013). Of the eight plates, five have fashionable designs from the Early Republic period molded in to the surface. The designs are comprised of a hanging basket of flowers and fruit, bows, swags of leaves, a variety of floral motifs, and beaded edging. Figures 2 and 3 demonstrate how the stove plates are assembled in to a fireplace.

Disassembled cast iron Franklin stove components laid flat showing all individual pieces including decorative top panel with swag garland relief, two paneled door sections, ornate side brackets with scrollwork, and curved base plate, all in black finish against white background.
Fig. 1 Five plates from the Catoctin Furnace Historical Society's Franklin stove, with manufacturing information and molded decoration, after conservation.
Black cast iron Franklin stove with open paneled doors installed in pale green painted fireplace surround.
Fig. 2 Example of a Franklin stove in situ at the Hopewell Furnace National Historic Site.

The stove made at Catoctin Furnace is called a Franklin because it is based on a model that was invented by Benjamin Franklin in the 1740's. Franklin’s original stove plate design incorporated a complex arrangement of heat exchanger and down-draft flue that would supposedly extract more heat from the fire's fumes and thus be more efficient in heating a room (Howell 2013). Unfortunately, the design did not work that well, or not at all, and the stove became a commercial failure for Franklin (Howell 2013). Franklin did not have a patent on his stove and subsequent inventors and manufacturers began simplifying and improving his design into a model that would become viable and functional. Throughout the 19th century, some of the improved models were patented and Franklin's prestigious name continued to be associated with that type of iron stove. The molded decoration on the stove plates also evolved and varied greatly, reflecting the changes in fashion over time.

Black-painted cast iron Franklin stove with open double doors revealing interior fire chamber with paneled design.
Fig. 3 Another example of a Franklin stove assembled. Collection of Winterthur Museum. Catalogue Number 1983.0210. http://museumcollection.winterthur.org

Despite its design flaws and the development of other modern heating sources, the Franklin stove continued to appeal to consumers, even in to the 20th century. In a Tod Hunter Inc. catalogue from 1930, the company offered a variety of reproduction Franklin stoves for sale (Figure 4). The Franklin stoves of the past, such as the one made at Catoctin Furnace, continue to be admired for their decorative qualities and exemplary display of iron casting technology.

Historical catalog page from showing Benjamin Franklin portrait medallion and three models of Pennsylvania Fireplace Franklin stoves.
Figure 4. A page from Tod Hunter Inc.’s 1930 catalogue, with a range of reproduction Franklin stoves for sale. http://archive.org/stream/GratesFranklinStovesFireFrames/GratesFranklinStovesFireplaces#page/n2/mode/1up

References

Anderson, Elizabeth Yourtee

​2013    Catoctin Furnace: Portrait of an Iron-Making Village. The History Press, Charleston.

Harris, Howell

​2013     A Stove Less Ordinary Blog: A Collection of Stoves from American Museums, Part II: Franklins. Web resource: http://stovehistory.blogspot.co.uk/2013/12/a-collection-of-stoves-from-american.html. Accessed 11 April 2016.

Hunter, Todd

​1930    Grates, Franklin Stoves & Fire Frames: Authentic Reproductions of Antique Originals by Tod Hunter Inc. Web resource: http://archive.org/stream/GratesFranklinStovesFireFrames/GratesFranklinStovesFireplaces#page/n2/mode/1up. Accessed 11 April 2016.

National Park Service

​2016    Catoctin Iron Furnace. Web resource: https://www.nps.gov/cato/learn/historyculture/furnace.htm. Accessed 11 April 2016.

About Curator's Choice

Curator's Choice is a monthly spotlight on a particular artifact or type of artifact from collections at the Maryland Archaeological Conservation Lab. Click on the link to see the essay as a web page. For most months, you can also view a formatted "poster-sized" image suitable for printing at a larger size.

About the MAC Lab

The MAC Lab

Contact Us

  [email protected]